Date: Sun, 15 Jun 2014 19:28:10 -0400 (EDT) From: A. Iku Subject: Rough Papi | Benito v. Carlito Rough Papi | Benito v. Carlito Just as Carlito and I finished, we heard Benny walk in. "Yo Carlito, Trae where you fools at?" Benny yelled from the front of the store, as we frantically put our clothes back on. We got ourselves dressed and together just in time, just as Benny made his way back to the storeroom where we were. "What you fools doing back here?" Benny asked, as he leaned in and kissed me on the forehead. The kiss, it was kind of awkward, weird. Like Benny was marking his territory something. Like he knew what had happen, like he sensed it. It was crazy because even though Carlito has always known about Benny and me, Benny never felt the need to be that touchy feely before, especially not kissing me in front of Carlito. That was definitely something new, something weird, something crazy. And more than that, the fact that he did it just seconds after almost catching me and his cousin fucking, was just too much. Then the way Carlito looked at us, was even weirder, even crazier. It was like Carlito was jealous. Like he wanted to be in Benny's place, or maybe even mine. See, that's what I mean, it was all so weird. It was like Carlito was jealous, but I wasn't sure of who. And Benny, I swear he knew what we did, like he could smell it on us. For a second after the kiss, we were all just quiet, almost too quiet. Then Carlito's expression changed. It went from jealously and shock to an almost unrecognizable nervousness that I had never seen from him before. Then suddenly, that same old cocky, asshole expression that Carlito always had, was suddenly plastered across his face. Then he gave me a look that was loud and clear, a "you better not say nothing" kind of look. And instinctually I knew to keep my mouth shut, and just go along with whatever he came up with to explain away this situation. "We just breaking down boxes cus. Since when is that a crime?" Carlito said in this almost too smooth kind of way, that made it almost damn near impossible, even for me, not to believe his story. I was just hoping it was enough to get by Benny. "What... you helping out now, cus?" Benny asked sarcastically, knowing that the last thing Carlito ever wanted to do was any of the grunt work in the store, yet along helping me out in any way. "Yeah what's wrong with that. This is my bodega too." Carlito said to his cousin, flashing a killer fucking smile. Carlito really was a smooth ass dude, almost as smooth as Benny. Nowhere near half the charm, though. But nearly just as sexy, in a totally different, arrogant asshole kind of way. But I see it now. Carlito is as hot of Papi as they come, maybe even hotter than Benny. And maybe if he wasn't always such a dick, I would've realised that sooner. But I guess that's what I kinda like about him, now. And the fact that right now, he was sort of saving the day for me, sort of saving my life, I couldn't help but find myself nearly hanging on his every word, all as if I didn't already know the truth. "Cus, we all gotta do our part, right." Carlito said, and I found myself nearly ready to burst out in laughter at his 'teamwork', 'company man' responses. It was hilarious, funny as hell. Almost so funny that I forgot just how terrified I really was, that at any minute my whole world could crash and burn right in front of me. But it was working, Benny was buying it. Then I realised, I hadn't said a word since Benny's been back. "Yeah Papi, he decided not to be an asshole today." I said laughing. Then jokingly, Carlito pushed me. It was kinda weird. It wasn't one of his usual, fuck you, I hate you type of pushes, it was a friendly, fucking loving, I just have to touch you kind of push. It was like our shared fear of Benny finding us out, had suddenly made us become friends, maybe more. I guess sex really can make two people become closer. But what we did, wasn't just sex. It was something more, something powerful, something dangerous; because I wanted more, and I knew he did too. But Benny, what about Benny? "Alright whatever, let me talk to you up front real quick cus." Benny said to Carlito. Then they left, and both headed up to the front, Carlito following not far behind his unknowing cousin. And just as he passed in front of me, Carlito smiled, licked his tongue at me, and grabbed a handful of my dick through my pants. It took everything in me, not to moan out his name. I just closed my eyes and bit my lip to stay quiet."You coming or what?" Benny shouted, snapping me out of my haze, nearly catching us again. But he didn't. Then as they both walked away, I whispered under my breathe,"You don't know how close I was to cumming Papi."... Later on, when we got home that night, tension was high. I swear on everything, I knew Benny had to know. Maybe I was just a bit paranoid. But all day, Carlito did everything he could to entice me, to remind me what we had done, as if I could forget. All day whether it was touching me or touching himself, or saying crazy shit to me like,"I always liked playing with Benny's toys, when he wasn't looking, even when we were ninos. I guess things never change, huh?" And that was on the tame side of things he said to me. And he wasn't exactly inconspicuous about it. It was like he didn't care, like he wanted to get caught, like he wanted Benny to hear him. It was like he felt untouchable. Like he could do whatever he wanted. But I knew better, I knew if he kept on like he was, this wasn't gonna end well... I forgot to mention, that at the time, not only did we work together, but Benny, Carlito and I sort of lived together too... I had pretty much been staying with Benny the whole summer. My mom didn't really care to ask where I was. I can't really be mad at her though. She hadn't really been the same since my sister died. And I knew she could barely take care of herself now, and I just didn't want to be any extra of a burden on her. So as long as I stayed out of trouble, she didn't ask and I didn't tell. Besides I was 15 now, and could take care of myself, and where I couldn't, I had Benny. So I was good. Carlito, he had been crashing on Benny's sofa for the last week or so, while he got some work done on his place. Which was ok, even when he hated me. But now after today, after what we had done, it was like hell. Here I was living with the guy I was supposed to love, while his sexy ass cousin, who I fucked up and had sex with today, was sleeping right in the next room. Man I was in hell. I didn't know what to do. I didn't know how to feel. And it felt like tonight of all nights, Benny wanted me more than he ever did before. "Come on babe, I know you want it." Benny said, with his hand down my briefs. We were in bed; and Carlito was just in the other room. "Come on Papito, when you start making me beg for it?" Benny was persistent, and he knew what he wanted. I just wasn't so sure I could give it to him, not tonight at least. But like I said he was persistent; and before I knew it, my dick was out and he was taking it down his throat. And it felt good. It felt good as shit. It was like he had something to prove. Like he wanted to show me just how good he could make me feel, just how hard he could make me cum. And I was nearly there, until I started thinking about today, and what I had done with Carlito. And all that thinking just brought everything to a halt. It was like Benny's mouth was pure torture on my guilty dick. "Stop, stop. I gotta piss Papi. Stop." I said anything, anything I could think of to get out of that room. I ran like hell down the hall to the bathroom. I just had to get away from Benny. And when I walked into the bathroom, there was Carlito waiting for me. "What the hell are you doing in here? I asked Carlito, who was just standing there, with that cocky fucking smile on his face, wearing nothing but his boxers. I found myself staring hard at his body, his perfect body. His strong chest, and shoulders cover in nearly a dozen tats. His tight fucking abs. Then I found myself look right at his dick. And in that moment, he just reminded me so much of my mom's old boyfriend Tito. "I'm waiting for you bitch." He said, and then I realised, he was nothing like Tito, yet I still wanted him more than ever. And after that everything that happened was all a blur........ The bathroom door shut. He grabbed me, maybe I grabbed him. We started kissing, touching, feeling each other all over. It was hot as fuck. Then he picked me up and put me on the sink. The water was on, I think. Yeah it was. I remember, my underwear were soaked. He was standing between my legs. We were kissing. Then he thrust his tongue in my mouth, and pushed me up against the mirror. He was so fucking rough. I loved that shit. Then he pulled me down off the sink, and pushed me into the door, and starting licking my neck. Slamming into the door, we were so loud, Benny must've heard it... The next thing I know, I hear Benny knocking on the door."What's going on in there Papito?" He asked. Carlito was wasting no time. He literally ripped my briefs right off my ass, and before I know it, he was inside me again. "Fuck!" I moaned. Carlto's fat Puerto Rican dick was made just for my ass. And he knew just how to make me scream. "What's going on? What's happening?" Benny shouted through the door. I could only image what he thought was happening on the other side of this door. "Come back later cus." Carlito moans, as he fucks the shit out of my ass. "What?" Benny yells. "Oh fuck no." "Mhmmm." I moan. "Come back later Papi. Mhmm fuck me Papi. Come back later. Cum Papi, cum." It felt so good, I didn't even care that Benny was there. "Oh fuck no." Benny continued through the door. Carlito was dicking me long, and deep, and hard, and rough. I love that rough shit. It was like he was trying to get his whole body inside me. And I was opened for it. I felt so full, yet I wanted more. He was slowly easing out of me, an inch at a time, until only the head was left inside. Then he jammed it all back in, as hard as he could. It felt so fucking good. And Benny just kept banging on the door, yelling insults. To be honest I couldn't tell you what he said; I was just too lost in the pleasure Carlito was giving to my ass. And then Carlito, started thrusting inside me harder and faster. I could tell he was getting close."Oh I'm cummin papito, I'm coming." Carlito whispered in my ear, as he picked up his. Then suddenly he stopped. "I feel it Papi. I feel it." I moaned out loud. "I'm gonna fucking kill you both." Benny shouts through the door. "Fuuuuuuck!" Carlito moans, as he shoots deep inside my hole. And then we both fall to the floor exhausted. We were spent, we had nothing left in us. We didn't even care about Benny's threats anymore, that he continued to yell through the door. Hell, we never cared or we wouldn't have done to begin with. We were just too lost in this haze of mind blowing, hard, rough, passionate sex, to care about anything. But as I laid there in a pool of sweat, next to Carlito, my papi's cousin of all people, with the intoxicating scent of forbidden sex in the air, I started to regret it all. Not just today or tonight, but I regretted ever getting into Benny's car that night. I regretted ever fantasizing about Benny through that arcade window. Fuck, I regret ever coming to Spanish Harlem. All I kept thinking was, "what's gonna happen now, what the fuck is Benny gonna do to us", as Benny continued to yell insults and threats through the door. And Carlito, he just laid there beside me, rubbing and playing with my dick... But I guess, I was one Papi too late to start thinking about what was gonna happen to me. I just hope it's not too rough, I thought. Then I came. And I was like,"fuck it, I like my Papi rough" ... And then Benny burst through the door...... To check out more of my stories, visit my site at :http://eroticwordsofiku.weebly.com/ And feel free to leave any thoughts and comments in my email at iku_iku227@aol.com And as always Don't Forget to Donate to Nifty!