Date: Mon, 30 Jan 2023 00:23:11 +0000 From: Rhett Blue Subject: My Cocky Brother Loses Our Bet AUTHOR'S NOTE: My stories involve sexual and romantic incest between brothers and cousins. I do not write other incest pairings under this pen name, so please do not request it. ---------- "My Cocky Brother Loses Our Bet" by Rhett Blue ---------- Naked in my big bro's tiny New York apartment, my strong hands were clamped onto the thick bar of the dumbbell, and my muscled legs were spread apart on either side of the bench press. Grinning, I eyed my (questionably straight) brother who lay beneath me in a navy jockstrap and black gym socks. His pink nipples and the rest of his smooth and toned body were fully exposed for my viewing pleasure. My long and thick dick was so close to his pretty-boy face, that a thick string of precum dripped over his lips, sticking like honey, except salty. "A bet is a bet, Jude," I said. "No turning back now since you promised you'd do it." "Oh, please, Jacob," he said in a clear voice, as deep as mine. "Like you even believed they'd win. Anyway, I'll just think of a hot girl who goes to the same university as me. I live in New York, remember? We're far more open-minded than people back home. Not a big deal." "But girls don't have dicks, so wouldn't mine break the immersion?" I playfully winked, aching to shove it into Jude's perfectly shaped mouth to see those full, cherry lips wrapped around my big, mushroom-like rod. "My imagination trumps yours with what little experience you have compared to me. Besides, you're the one who loves dick, not me." Jude winked back with a smirk, seemingly more cocky than playful as he relaxed on the bench press, completely unbothered. At one point, I was straight, too, until I really wasn't---no one but Jude knew the truth. A daily view of naked bodies, nice dicks, and round asses in the boys' locker room told my dick otherwise, not that I'd dare to make a move on any of them. But I'd hit the jackpot, anyway. Jude was not only available to mess around with; he was a better candidate for a potential fuck buddy. Masculine like me, and while clean, he smelled manly enough to trigger my pheromones, with just a hint of whatever expensive cologne his face sold all over the TV ads, plus the man musk. But was he really as straight as he claimed, given his lack of discomfort? God, look at him... Jude really was a beautiful runway model for our well-known cousin's fashion shows: dirty-blond hair gelled in a purposefully messy style, olive-green eyes that held a high dose of confidence, smooth skin that was permanently kissed by the sun, and a lean build with sexy muscle definition. He was nineteen in college, not too much older than me, but already independently on his own. Meanwhile, I had similar physical features, enough to totally look like his brother without being a twin. However, I was less tall (but not short) and more buff (but not beefy), and I had a big bubble butt compared to his smaller one. I also still lived back home in rural Wisconsin, and still in high school. I had to be careful, though. As a young jock who could be both stingy and greedy with some stuff, I could easily see myself becoming possessive and refusing to share my big bro with anyone, given all the envious attention he got in New York City, Los Angeles, London, Paris, and Milan, among other places. But Jude wasn't my possession, and I had to remind myself that more often than I probably should. He gave me a cocky smirk and licked the precum off his lips while my leaking dick remained dangerously close to his face. "I'm only doing this because I lost the bet, so don't get the wrong idea. I'm straight, remember that." "I know." We'd made many bets before, but the outcome had never been remotely sexual. For the last one he'd lost, the Lions had shockingly knocked the Packers out of the playoffs, practically giving us heart attacks. To be fair, I'd been convinced it wouldn't have happened because, well, when did it? It was supposed to be an easy bet while we'd both drunk enough beer to be a wee too open-minded---Mom and Dad would kill me if they knew I drank at my age. Yet here we were on the bench press, about to do what brothers weren't supposed to be doing, not that I was complaining. "So, go ahead, my sweet little brother. Take all those horny frustrations out on me and fill my throat with your young seed." I giggled at how straight of a face Jude had when he'd said it, dripping lots more precum because he was right about my hormones, even though he was hardly much older to justify the playful condescension. "I guess having a big dick has its perks," I said. "No wonder you want to hide yours in a jockstrap." Not that Jude was hard in his jockstrap for me to know for sure, but I probably was bigger. "Oh, you're big, indeed." He wiggled his tongue to signal me to move my dick closer to his face, and for the first time, his tongue made contact with my forbidden flesh. He licked around the head and collected every drop of precum that oozed from the piss slit. I had to be careful because I was ready to blow my load in an instant. I tried to fight the urge, always coming too fast when watching porn. This was my first sexual experience---with my own brother whose blood and DNA we shared, no less---and I wanted it to mean something. What I wanted it to mean, I had yet to figure out. All I knew was that I wished I could move in with Jude. It wasn't that I particularly cared about New York, since I'd feel the same way about anywhere in the world, but I just needed him in my life. Wherever he went, I wanted to go. If that made me seem too attached, then so be it. At least he was always willing to pay for my way to see him, since he apparently made lots of money. He continued licking just the head, swirling his tongue around and slathering the head with his saliva. He did this while his green gaze held mine with so much control, all while forming his cocky smirk. "I'm straight, but you can come all over my face if you want." I lifted my eyebrows. "Oh. Really? That wouldn't weird you out?" "What, a facial? Of course not. Semen is good for the skin. I take care of myself very well, as you can see." Jude gestured with a wave toward his body as if unveiling a new car in the way the female models do all the time at auto shows. What an arrogant ass, but I loved him no matter what. He grabbed one of my butt cheeks and gave it a light spank. "Damn, Jacob. Your fat ass is bigger than I realized, and I can tell it jiggles just by feeling it." I wasn't sure why, but that comment kind of pricked my heart a bit, making me question just what he was trying to say after I'd regularly kept up with working out. I wasn't fat at all; I just had a butt that happened to be big and round. Since I lived in the middle of nowhere with townsfolk on the conservative side, there wasn't anyone who'd mention my butt, and I hadn't felt too bothered by it until now. "Don't be sad about it. Believe me, it's a good thing." Jude winked. "Oh," I said in a breath of relief. Maybe he knew much more about sex than I'd realized, even though he was straight. But why was his hand still on my ass? And why was his warm touch making me hornier? He licked some more precum, then finally opened his mouth to start sucking just the mushroom-like head, his tight gaze never letting go of mine. Shit, was he trying to make me come already? For being straight, he sure was comfortable doing this, not that I'd ever complain about his warm mouth on me. He continued burning his olive-green eyes into mine as his cheeks sank in with every suck. He gave my butt cheek a firmer squeeze and spanked it harder this time. I flinched from the mild sting, but somehow, I kind of liked it. "Well, well. You actually like that." I shrugged. "Maybe." Jude spanked my butt again, looking like he really enjoyed this. "You like being a naughty little boy. My bad little brother." I didn't say another word, but if being naughty meant it led to this level of brotherly bonding, then I was all for it. I'd do anything at this point. Jude used his other hand to rub my nipple, his thumb slowly caressing the hard, pink nub to create a familiar electricity I'd experienced many times when rubbing my own nipples. He let go of my dick and smirked. "How's it feel, Jacob?" I expressed a shy grin but was too horny to actually be shy. "Good," I said in a hard breath. "Real good." "Yeah?" I gave him a nod. "Even though I can be a cocky prick, you do know that I love you, right?" I nodded again, smiling widely. "I love you, too, Jude. Always." Was that a horny look on his face? No, he was straight, remember? "Maybe I should start flying you over here more often to get you off." Oh, shit, I was so ready to burst, my insides melting just from gazing into those sexy eyes. Jude would be the best fuck buddy ever, not that I knew what it was like to have one. "But I'm straight, so don't get the wrong idea just because a guy is willing to help his little brother out by relieving some stress." I nodded yet again and felt the urge rising higher as he continued sucking just the head, his eyes still on mine while we connected like never before. This brotherly bond we had was like no other, just two blood-related bodies incestuously exploring each other. Jude let go again and smirked, with one hand still on my ass and the other rubbing my nipple. "I want you to give me a facial because I'm not sure if I'd like the taste. So, let's just start with my face." Not that I was far from doing so. In fact, I was dangerously close... "Do it, Jacob. You've wanted this for a while. You were praying I lost the bet just so you can act out your incest fantasies like a dirty little fucker. And don't lie to me." I just formed a shy grin, speechless because it was the truth. "You love being dirty with your big brother." Jude slapped my ass and smirked. "Maybe I need to take some notes from you and make a bet that's easy for you to lose, just so I can fuck the shit out of you." Closer... "Ever been fucked? I'm guessing no." I shook my head. "I mean, I made out with a girl I used to date, but, you know, I never wanted to take it that far." "You're a virgin, then. Of course. I mean, what guy would you do it with in Wisconsin, of all places." Jude always put our home state down, even when he'd lived there his whole life. In a way, it was like he was running away from something, but maybe it was just in my head. "Come for me, Jacob. Shoot that pent-up load. You wanted this so bad, so do it." Closer... "Fucking do it. Now." A raised tone. Losing it completely, I started gasping, my heavy eyes starting to roll to the back of my head. With his hand squeezing my butt cheek and his other one rubbing my nipple, I shot an insane amount of cum all over my big brother's pretty-boy face, moaning from the intense pleasure. I could hear a few thuds on the wall and on the leather padding of the bench press. To my surprise, Jude lifted his head to take more of my length while I still came, devouring almost half my dick. His warm mouth sucked the rest of my cum like a vacuum as it flooded his throat. Never had I imagined he would swallow cum, let alone give a blowjob. My body shook as my balls emptied out the last few drops, the finale of my first sexual experience. What a mind-blowing time I'd just had with my big bro. I didn't care that it was incest; reading a lot of brother stories on Nifty kind of normalized it in my head. Spent, I giggled from the ticklish sensation of Jude's vacuum-tight mouth still on my dick after I'd been drained. "Ow, ow, it's sensitive." I let out another giggle. It took him a moment to let go of my dick, as if taunting me just to make me squirm, while his green gaze still held mine. He smirked, seemingly unfazed about what we'd just done together, which was odd for a straight guy. God, I loved Jude so much. He was everything to me. "I have a big surprise for you, Jacob." "Oh. What is it?" "Take a look below." I did, and my jaw dropped at the sight of one of the biggest dicks I'd ever seen in my life, fully erect as it peeked out from Jude's jockstrap as if too big to fit inside. Wow, he'd lied to me! Well, more like he'd made me feel like an idiot for thinking I'd been bigger this whole time, but still. I swallowed with intimidation, and my stomach tightened at the thought of possibly losing our next bet like he'd lost the recent one. His dick was practically a monster mushroom, longer than mine by a few inches and noticeably thicker. Being lean didn't help him because it looked even bigger. "Between us, I once overheard Mom complaining about Dad's size when they argued over not having sex anymore. Now I know why. But if you ask me, I'd say it's more a blessing than a curse." Jude winked. Yeah. A big blessing... He sighed. "So, we're still on for a new bet of my choosing, and there's no turning back after this. I'll let you know what it is soon. But since your horny little mind came up with the idea of having a straight guy suck you off---your own brother, no less---it's only fair that you ride me in return if you lose the next bet. We'll see just how much your fat ass jiggles with every hard thrust I give you. In a jockstrap, of course." Oh... "Payback is a virgin-tight bitch, isn't it?" Another smirk. Staring at that scary monster again, that suspiciously started leaking, I suddenly prayed I wouldn't lose. "I-I don't have condoms, though." "Silly, Jacob. I've never fucked a guy before, and you're a virgin." True... "Besides, what fun is it if I can't breed your hole and introduce you to your tiny nephews." Jude chuckled. "And then, I'm going to do it over and over and over again. Make you beg for it. Make you need my huge dick like a hungry little fucker. And you're going to love every inch of it." Now, I felt conflicted. There was no possible way that thing would fit inside my virgin butthole. At the same time, there was no other guy I'd ever want to take my virginity than my own brother. Jude had earned it, if just because I was falling hard and fast for him. ---------- Thanks for reading. Feel free to give any honest feedback because I always like knowing what my readers think. All my publications are linked on my website, including ebooks and web stories. Also, please help Nifty out with a donation! Email: rhettblue@proton.me Website: https://rhettblue.wordpress.com DISCLAIMER: All characters in this work are fictitious. Any resemblance to real people, living or dead, is purely coincidental. (c) 2023, Rhett Blue. All rights reserved.