Date: Thu, 13 Jul 2017 15:23:01 -0700 From: Jojo Starr Subject: A Sister's Confusion - Chapter 3 Copyright by the author, 2017. No reproductions without the author's permission. A Sister's Confusion Chapter 3 As much as the girls wanted to stay in that position forever, they knew their parents would be getting home later that day, which forced them to actually get up and get dressed. The hard part was trying to act like everything was normal, when it was now clear that they had passionately strong feelings for each other. They could hardly keep their eyes off of each other the rest of the day. Ashley couldn't believe how much she loved her sister, how hard she'd fallen so quickly. Every chance she got, she stole glances at her sister, admiring her gorgeous eyes, her slightly toussled hair from their lovemaking earlier, her perfect skin, and her beautiful, sweet mouth that she yearned to kiss over and over, again and again, all day long. She also had a hard time keeping her eyes off her sister's chest. Each time she looked at her sister's breasts, she was reminded of them bouncing up and down on her chest as they made love, and it got her terribly aroused. How she longed to see them do that again. And she also caught herself noticing another part of her sister that she'd never really paid much attention to before - her butt. She was surprised to find her eyes continually wandering to that part of her sister, feeling a wonderful little thrill each time they did. In short, she was a mess. Hopelessly in love with her sister, and hopelessly aroused by every single part of her body. It didn't help that Alyssa smiled back whenever she looked at her, with those sparkling blue eyes, lighting up the room with that radiantly gorgeous smile, sometimes adorably trying to suppress a giggle, and sometimes adorably letting one escape. She never believed anything could feel so wonderful as this. To so appreciate every gorgeous thing about someone so perfect and wonderful, someone she'd known her whole life and loved dearly, and had now experienced the most intimate things a person can experience with another. It was absolutely beautiful. The hard part was trying to keep it together around their parents. That was definitely a struggle for both of them, but they did the best they could. Ashley couldn't be sure her parents hadn't caught a glace or two of them staring at each other with absolute ga-ga looks in their eyes, but she tried to play it off like it was nothing. If anything, her parents probably thought they were sharing some kind of secret that their parents didn't want to know about, like most teenage girls do. Which was exactly the case, only normal teenage girls don't have this kind of secret from their parents! That night, as their parents headed off to bed, Ashley and Alyssa shot each other a look from across the living room. They had been sitting apart all evening, not trusting themselves to not do something stupid in front of their parents. But now, their parents were heading down the hall and the girls locked eyes excitedly. Ashley bit her lip, her body tense as she waited for the sound of their parents' bedroom door closing. She could see the same look mirrored on her sister's face - heavy, intense sexual tension sprung back, just ready for release. And then... click. The door was closed. Immediately, the girls jumped up from the couch, rushing toward each other. They met in the middle of the room and embraced tightly, gripping each other's mouths firmly with their lips. They sighed heavily, relishing in the feel of their bodies pressed together once again. They kissed hotly, Ashley's hands going to either side of her sister's face, holding it so she could control precisely where and how she placed her lips against Alyssa's. Their lips gripped each other over and over, unable to get enough. After nearly a full minute of torrid kissing, the girls began to gasp for air. "Oh my GOD, I've been wanting to do that all day!" Ashley gasped. Alyssa grinned. "Me too," she breathed, "even though it's only been a couple of hours since we last did it." "God, it feels like an eternity," Ashley sighed, looking into her sister's eyes and still holding her face. "Kissing you just feels so amazing!" she said as she leaned in and covered her sister's lips with her own once more. "Mmmmmmh," Alyssa moaned, sighing into the kiss. Her hands slid up her sister's back, pressing her close. The girls kissed passionately for another minute or so, until Ashley reluctantly pulled back, gasping for air and looking dreamily into her sister's eyes. "We... shouldn't get too carried away," she panted. A brief moment of disappointment crossed Alyssa's face, but she understood. "Yeah," she sighed in agreement. "Not with mom and dad in the house," Ashley said. "It's too risky." "I know," Alyssa said. "But we can cuddle... on the couch," Ashley said, "...and maybe make out a little," she said, a grin spreading across her face. "As long as we mostly keep our hands to ourselves." "I can live with that," Alyssa said, grinning. Ashley pecked her sister on the lips, then pulled her down to the couch where they both settled back into the cushions, Ashley curled up toward her sister, Alyssa sitting with her legs draped over Ashley's, their bodies close. "I missed you," Alyssa said, looking into her sister's eyes, rubbing her arms gently. "I missed you too," Ashley said, pecking her sister on the lips once again. "I just wanna be close to you all day long." "Me too," Alyssa said. The girls looked into each other's eyes for a few moments until Ashley rolled her eyes back, closing them softly, tilting her head back slightly as she sighed. "God," she breathed when she opened her eyes again. "I can't believe this is happening!" Alyssa grinned, looking into her sister's eyes. "I know. It's crazy, isn't it?" "Yeah... I mean... there are, like, no words to describe it. I have never felt this way in my life about anyone, ever," Ashley said. "Me either," Alyssa said, grinning, her eyes sparkling. "I mean... we're sisters..." Ashley said. "Isn't that weird?" Alyssa paused briefly. "I guess so," she said. "But it's also, like... kinda cool." "Yeah, we've, like, known each other forever... we live with each other..." Ashley then bit her lip as she grinned, wondering if she should say what she was really thinking. She searched her sister's eyes briefly, and decided to go ahead. "And it's almost like the fact that we're sisters kinda makes it even hotter," she said, feeling herself blush as she did. "I know, totally!" Alyssa said excitedly, giggling as a blush rose to her face as well. Ashley giggled with her, blushing even more at how adorable it was that they were both a bit embarrassed by admitting that being involved with their sister was a turn-on. When their slightly awkward, slightly embarrassed giggling died down, Ashley looked back into her sister's eyes, feeling a flood of emotions all over again. "It's like... I've known you my whole life," she said, "...and now I get to know a whole other side of you." "I know," Alyssa said, nodding. "It's like this whole thing is just bringing us so much closer together." Ashley grinned, then kissed her sister on the lips. It wasn't quite a peck, lingering just a little bit longer. When she pulled back, Alyssa looked up dreamily into her eyes. Ashley could stare at that face forever, she thought. Slowly, Alyssa moved her hand along Ashley's thigh, rubbing it gently. Ashley cuddled against her sister, cradling her head against hers. They sat like that, holding each other for a minute or so. Then Alyssa spoke. "I had no idea you were even into girls until the other day," Alyssa said. "When did you first know?" "I dunno," Ashley said. "I guess it was always kinda there. I mean, I have nothing against guys, really, it's just... girls are just so much more... beautiful, and soft, and sweet. I just think they're so much sexier. I guess I've always felt that way." "I think I have too," Alyssa said softly. Ashley raised her head and looked at her sister. "Really?" "Yeah, kinda," she said, blushing slightly. "I guess I just never wanted to admit it or do anything about it. I was... scared, I guess." Ashley nodded. "I know what you mean. It is kinda scary, especially coming from this family." "God, I know! Can you even imagine what mom and dad would do if they found out about us??" Alyssa said. Ashley just shook her head, her eyes wide. "I don't even want to think. Which is why they're NEVER gonna find out." "Yeah, I know," Alyssa said. She was quiet for a bit. Then she spoke softly. "When did you know... with me?" Ashley paused for a second, then raised her head. "When did I know I was into you?" Alyssa nodded, blushing slightly. Ashley furrowed her brows as she thought. "I dunno," she said honestly. "That's a tough one. I've always thought you were really pretty... and a beautiful person. There were even times, once or twice maybe, where I caught myself checking you out." "Really??" Alyssa said, her eyes widening as her face spread into a grin. "Like when?" Ashley blushed. "I dunno... just, like, randomly, really. Like whenever you were wearing something really nice. Or had, like, really short shorts. Or maybe once or twice in your bathing suit. Why, are you saying you never did anything like that with me?" Alyssa turned red as she bit her lip. "You did, didn't you!" Ashley chided. "I couldn't help it!" Alyssa pleaded. "You're, like, really hot!" "Well thanks," Ashley said, grinning. "So are you." She paused for a second. "Anyway, those times were, like, really brief and the feeling barely lasted. I didn't really think much of it. I just figured you were really pretty and figured it was normal to think that. Actually, it wasn't until you came home from Sabrina's that I really started to, like... notice you." "Really?" Alyssa asked. "Yeah," Ashley said. "I could tell you were really frustrated and I had a hint that maybe you were into her. And then, like, something flipped. The fact that you might be into girls was, like, a revelation. It made me see you in a totally different way, and it made you seem, like, ridiculously sexy." "Really?" Alyssa asked. Ashley nodded. "And then... when you flopped down onto the bed, you were like this absolutely perfect, beautiful being. I felt drawn to you in a way I'd never felt before. All I wanted to do was just lay down next to you, and then when I did, it was just so intense and I felt like I wasn't in control anymore. All I could think about was your face and your lips and how beautiful they were. I wanted to kiss you so bad it hurt." She looked into her sister's eyes, feeling the same thing all over again. "It was at that exact moment," she said, "that I fell for you. And I knew there was no turning back." They were quiet for a second. "When I looked up at you," Alyssa said, vividly recalling the moment, "I thought you were the most beautiful person I'd ever seen. I trusted you completely. I knew it everywhere in my body. I would have done anything you asked." Ashley bit her lip, losing herself in her sister's gorgeous eyes. "When we moved together... that night..." she practically whispered. "It was the most perfect thing I've ever felt." "Me too..." Alyssa breathed, her face inches from her sister as she tilted her face up toward her. Ashley moved closer. And at the last second, she turned away. "Oh my God, I want to SO BAD!" she groaned in exasperation. "Why can't we?" Alyssa asked. "Just one kiss?" "Because I don't think I'll be able to control myself!" Ashley said. "You're just too fucking hot!" Alyssa bit her lip. "I'm sorry," she said, blushing slightly. Ashley met her eyes again and sighed. "God, every time I look at you I just wanna grab you and press you to me and fuck you so hard till I make you scream!" Alyssa's eyelids fluttered closed. "God, that sounds so hot," she breathed. "Do you have any idea how hot you make me?" Ashley sighed. "If it's anything close to how hot you make me, then, yeah, I do," Alyssa giggled. "I mean... I just can't stop thinking about you... and us... together. It's driving me crazy!" Ashley said, throwing her head back and staring at the ceiling. "I know what you mean," Alyssa said. After another second or so, Ashley felt a little bit of movement next to her. She looked down and her eyes widened. Alyssa's hand had slipped into the waistband of her pants and was moving around. Ashley looked back at her sister's eyes, which were staring right back into hers. "Are you... touching yourself?" Ashley gasped. Alyssa nodded. "If we can't touch each other, then I'm just going to do it myself." Ashley couldn't believe how sexy her sister was right then. Her heart began to race as she became incredibly aroused. "Oh my God," she breathed. "You are so hot I can't stand it." With that, she slipped her own hand down and inside her panties. Keeping her eyes locked on her sister's, she sighed as she pressed her fingers against her moist clit and began to rub herself. Alyssa sighed, her eyes moving down to watch Ashley's hand slip under her panties. She bit her lip as her eyes moved back up to her sister's. "Oh my God," Ashley moaned breathily, staring deep into her sister's eyes. "We're really gonna do this, aren't we?" Alyssa just nodded, her breathing slightly heavier. Ashley felt a jolt of intense energy course through her at the realization that she would get to cum again while looking at her sister's face. And nothing - absolutely nothing - got her hotter than watching her sister's beautiful face twist up into orgasm. That in itself would probably get her to cum, she realized, and she probably wouldn't even need to touch herself. Just then, Alyssa twitched, and Ashley's eyes darted down, watching the lump of her sister's hand in her shorts bob and jerk around with faster movements. It spurred Ashley to rub herself faster as she felt herself get wetter and wetter. Her eyes quickly went back up to Alyssa's, where she received yet another jolt of energy. Alyssa's eyes were intense, hot, burning. Her mouth had fallen open and it was clear she was intensely aroused, well on her way to a climax. Ashley gasped, shocked at how intensely erotic it was to be staring into her sister's eyes as they rubbed themselves. All of her senses were heightened and every nerve in her body stood at maximum altertness, waiting and watching with intense anticipation for the slightest indication that her sister was getting closer to her orgasm. Alyssa's jaw lowered slightly, her lip twitched. The rhythm of her rubbing was constant and quick. Alyssa's chest heaved with an unexpected gasp and her hips gave a small involuntary jerk upward. Her eyebrows lowered and tensed, her jaw lowering slightly further. Each of these tiny little movements from her sister sent a heavy jolt of erotic energy coursing through Ashley's body, knowing her sister was getting closer, bringing her closer as well. Ashley could feel her own body making little involuntary movements as well, knowing that Alyssa was paying just as close attention to them as she was to Alyssa's. It was incredibly erotic to be seen like this, knowing she was making her sister hotter and hotter. They each studied the other's faces, bodies, and rhythms, bringing each other closer with every little jerk and gasp they made. As Ashley felt her clit, slick with her own juices, she briefly, just for a flash, imagined that it was Alyssa's, and that she was rubbing her sister's sex, bringing her to the edge of orgasm. That the look on Alyssa's face was the result of her - Ashley's - touch. It was unexpectedly hot, and it caused Ashley to grunt breathily, her hips jerking forward. Alyssa's jaw dropped and the bulge in her shorts began jerking rapidly back and forth. She inhaled sharply, holding her breath as she jerked her wrist heavily, the fabric loudly rustling, her legs spreading, her hips slowly rising. Ashley felt a heavy jolt of energy course through her as she watched her sister. It was unbelievably hot. She jerked her fingers rapidly across her clit, spreading her slick juices across it, her eyes focused intensely on her sister's face. 'Do it,' she told Alyssa with her eyes. 'Cum for me.' Alyssa exhaled sharply, inhaling again just as fast in a single heavy pant, her hips continuing to rise, the bulge in her shorts becoming a rapid blur. It was absolutely beautiful. Then she gasped again just as powerfully, holding it. The energy that coursed through Ashley's body at the knowledge her sister was climaxing shocked her as she sped up her fingers heavily, sliding her juices rapidly over her throbbing, engorged clit. Her clit suddenly burned. Hot. "Fuck!" she gasped, her brows tightening. "Oh fuckohfuckohfuck!" Alyssa gasped and her face twisted up tight, just as her hips and thighs tightened, her back arching heavily. Her tight body suddenly burst into tight, hot trembles, her eyes still locked on her sister's. Ashley felt a shocking burst of pleasure erupt from her loins as she stared into her sister's eyes, knowing she was cumming. She focused on the tightly contorted expressions of her sister's face - the most beautiful sight she had ever witnessed - as waves of almost painful pleasure coursed and pulsed through her body. Alyssa's body jerked and twisted, her movements and expressions so primal, so completely uninhibited, they were almost surreal. Ashley was shocked that Alyssa allowed her to witness her body in such a state of raw, carnality, and it drove her to another peak, as a powerful second burst of pleasure seized and shook her body. They jerked, bucked, panted, and writhed through three more consecutive orgasms, their eyes never leaving each other. Ashley held her sister's gaze until her vision blurred, reducing Alyssa to the sexiest trembling blob she had ever encountered. Ashley's hips continued bucking well after her body collapsed into the cushions, her body involuntarily jerking with aftershocks as she desperately gasped for breath. She felt Alyssa jerking and trembling against her as well as she came down from her own peaks. She was hot, sweaty, panting, and absolutely glowing. After enough oxygen returned to her brain to allow her to see properly again, she realized she was staring at her sister's chest. She found it extremely difficult to raise her eyes any higher than this. 'Not that this is a bad view,' she told herself as she recovered. After a few more breaths, she gathered the strength to raise her eyes back up to her sister's face. She found that Alyssa was already looking at her, and watched her sister's beautiful lips spread into a smile. It produced such a warmth in her chest that Ashley found herself smiling without even trying. Alyssa looked exhausted, her eyes half lidded, her body limp. But her smile was gorgeous. Ashley realized she must look pretty similar to Alyssa and almost giggled, but didn't quite have the energy for that. She was content to just smile lazily at her beautiful sister, basking in the afterglow of a series of incredibly powerful orgasms. "Wow," Ashley finally managed to breathe after another minute or so. Alyssa's eyebrows slowly rose, her eyes remaining half-lidded. "Yeaahh," she breathed. "That was..." she trailed off, and just as she was about to speak, Ashley stepped in. "Intense," the girls said simultaneously, immediately breaking out into involuntary giggles. "Seriously though," Ashley said, her voice lowering to not be so loud. "I can't believe how incredible that was. I had no idea that just doing... that... could be so hot." "I know," Alyssa said. "I'm still not sure I can move yet." "God, the way you moved," Ashley said, her eyes rolling back in her head at the recollection. "I've never cum so hard in my life!" "Really?" Alyssa asked, somewhat intrigued. "I didn't even realize what I was doing." "I know, that's what makes it so hot!" Ashley said. "You are just... so uninhibited... you get so caught up in the moment. It's like nothing else in the world matters but what you're feeling right then." Alyssa almost looked slightly confused. "Well... yeah," she said. "Isn't that what it's like for you too?" "Yeah, I guess," Ashley said. "I mean, it is... It's just... with you... I dunno, you're just so beautiful when you do it." "Thanks," Alyssa said, her cheeks turning slightly pink. They stared at each other for another minute or so, just glowing. "You don't think we were too loud, do you?" Ashley asked. "I dunno, I hope not," Alyssa said. "I think we were pretty quiet." Ashley bit her lip, a little smile forming on her face. "Does this mean we can do it again?" "Maybe," Alyssa said, returning her sister's mischievous smile with one of her own. "But right now I think we should probably get some rest." "Yeah," Ashley agreed. "That totally wore me out!" "I know, me too!" Alyssa giggled softly. Ashley pulled her hand out of her panties and leaned over, cupping her sister's face in both hands, planting her lips firmly against Alyssa's. "I love you... so much," she said, pulling back, realizing that her juices were now on Alyssa's face and hoping that Alyssa found it as sexy as she did. "I love you too," Alyssa said, pulling her own hand out of her panties and placing it on the same hand Ashley had in hers. Ashley grinned, sliding her fingers over her sister's and intertwining them, mixing their slick juices together. "You're dirty," Alyssa said, grinning. "I know. And you love me for it," Ashley said. "I do," Alyssa said, leaning in for one more kiss. ***************************************************** To be continued...