Identically Incorrigible Twins

They lived and laughed and loved and left–––James Joyce

Part 2

Zooey sat on the down–turned lid of the toilet bowl nervously watching the three high–definition color images from the hidden cameras, complete with audio, on the laptop in her lap as her sister approached Ben and circled his asshole with first a finger and then the tip of her tongue. While she never liked doing such things, she was incredibly aroused watching Abby prepare her husband the same way she did her for what was probably going to be the most thorough and intense ass fucking of his life.

With her pussy twitching uncontrollably, Zooey put the laptop on the vanity next to the commode and opened the bag of toys her sister brought from home. Three shiny black anal plugs of various sizes quite deliberately and suggestively lay on top of the other items. She picked up the largest and glanced at the screen where, from three different angles, she could see Abby finger–fucking her husband's asshole and hear his squeals of delight as he thrashed against her sister's hand.

“You're such a dirty–minded, cock–loving, pussy–eating, ass–fucking, cum–drinking cunt, Abby,” Zooey muttered to herself as she dug some lube out of the toy bag, generously coated the largest butt plug and slowly shoved it all the way into her own asshole. “God, I so fucking love it and it looks and sounds like my husband does too.”

She sat back down on the commode and spread her thighs until her pussy slit gaped open. She wiggled slightly to let the butt plug settle better before pinching her half–inch–long clit in two fingers. Her cunt instantly drooled pussy juices as she watched her sister lick her husband's asshole and jerk off his rigid dick.

Her body jerked as she ever so lightly touched the tip of her clit with a vibrator as three of Abby's fingers disappeared in turn inside Ben's asshole. Her first climax began with her husband cumming all over their sheets without a touch other than Abby's fingers in his bowels and finished with four spurts of Zooey's pussy juice pooling on the bathroom floor when Abby gobbled down some of Ben's cum then smeared even more on her tits and lips.

Zooey couldn't help herself.

When Abby positioned the head of the strap–on dildo against Ben's asshole, Zooey silently opened the bathroom door, slipped into the bedroom and soundlessly moved to one side. She just had to directly see her sister ram the fake cock in and out of her husband's bowels while he howled his pleasure.

The harder and faster her sister pounded her husband's asshole, the closer she moved to them. Abby was so involved in fucking Ben's ass, as well as her own building climax, she didn't notice Zooey and Ben was facing away from her.

Despite cumming mere minutes before, another orgasm quickly intensified deep in Zooey's lava–hot cunt. She rubbed her clit with abandon the closer she got. She suddenly caught a whiff of her husband's shit covering the dildo as it almost slipped completely out of his asshole. Rather than pushing her away in disgust as happened in the past, the pungent earthy fragrance added to her mushrooming excitement.

Then Abby flipped on the strap–on's vibration function.

Both her sister and her husband wailed and flailed uncontrollably. A soft moan escaped Zooey's lips despite her effort to muffle the sound with her free hand as she squirted another orgasm down the inside of her legs to soak the carpet at her feet. Neither Abby nor Ben seemed to notice as they collapsed together when their climaxes crested and dissipated, with Abby laying on his back with the strap–on dildo still halfway inside his asshole.

After a few moments, Abby stirred and straightened up with the tip of the dildo still in Ben's asshole. She jumped in surprise when Zooey came up behind her, wrapping her arms around her sister to gently fondle both of Abby's erect nipples.

“That's. So. Fucking. Hot!” Zooey murmured softly in Abby's ear as she felt her sister's ass pressing back against her soaked pussy.

Abby turned her head and smiled at Zooey then raised a finger to her lips, indicating Zooey should stay quiet. She turned back to Ben and slowly pulled the shit–covered dildo all the way out of his gaping asshole.

“Stay right there and rest for a moment,” she told him huskily, “and I'll be right back to do even more in a few minutes.”

Then Abby took Zooey's arm and pulled her into the bathroom where they could speak in whispers. She absentmindedly caressed the shit–covered cock as they talked, the same way she did when Zooey didn't adequately prepare herself in advance for one of their ass–fucking sessions.

“Do you want him to know I'm here and the one fucking his asshole?” Abby asked incredulously.

“At this point, I don't really care,” Zooey replied with a wicked grin. “I know you. I'm sure you have no intention of leaving here until you feel his cock in your cunt and taste his cum in your mouth. After watching that, I honestly have absolutely no objection to you doing that or anything else you want to and with him. In fact, I want to do it all with both of you until none of us can cum any longer. So, we might as well make this surprise as good as possible.”

“Do you want to take over?” Abby grinned, starting to unbuckle the strap–on.

“Oh no, I want you to finish what you started,” Zooey answered while pinching both her nipples. “Go back and fuck him in the ass while he jerks off, just like you told him. I'll break the news to him that there's more going on than he suspects in my own way.”

•••••

When Abby walked back to the bed, Ben was still lying on his stomach breathing raggedly. He grinned up at her when she told him to roll on his back and scoot down so his ass was barely on the edge of the bed.

“Ready for the next round?” she smiled mischievously, stepping between his legs and taking his still–deflated dick in her right hand.

“That was so amazing, I'll do anything you ask” he moaned lowly as his dick again hardened in her hand, “anything...everything...just tell me what you want or need me to do.”

“Close your eyes and keep your legs spread wide,” Abby replied softly, brushing a drop of precum from the tip of his cock with the pad of her thumb. “I'll take care of the rest.”

Ben continued smiling as he moved where she wanted and closed his eyes. Very quickly his thighs began to tremble as she steadily stroked his stiffening dick. After a minute or so, Abby turned the vibration back on and lightly pressed the tip of the fake cock against Ben's balls before slowly dragging it the length of his six–and–a–half–inch uncut shaft then tantalizingly circling the head.

“Oh god, that feels so damn good. Please...please...fuck me...again,” he moaned as he pushed his hips toward her, “as hard and as deep as you can.”

“Anything you want, anything at all,” Abby grinned as she slowly slid the thick pulsating fake dick back into his asshole. “This is all about you, letting you feel things and cum like never before.”

Even before she had the strap–on dildo all the way back inside Ben's bowels, Abby could see her sister slowly sneaking closer in the corner of her eye. When she was close enough, Zooey silently dropped to her knees next to them, pushed Abby's hand away from his dick and began jerking him off, keeping pace with Abby's thrust as she fucked him faster and faster.

“Oh fuck, babe...that's so good...I'm close...so fucking close,” he moaned, his dick throbbing in Zooey's hand and his back arching off the bed, “now...right...fucking...now!”

Just as his cum began to spurt from the head of his dick, Zooey rose and engulfed his cock with her mouth. At the same time, Abby pressed the vibrating tip of the fake shaft against his prostate hard and held it there as tightly as she could manage while he flopped around wildly. After he finally stopped cumming in her mouth, his cock slowly deflated and he slumped back, Zooey got to her feet and stood facing him with her arm around her sister's waist.

When he finally opened his eyes, he sat up with a start with his mouth agape.

“What. The. Fuck!” he exclaimed in surprise, looking back and forth at them, momentarily thinking he'd cum so hard he was seeing double.

Except, the one on his right was still wearing a shit–coated strap–on around her waist and a string of thick creamy cum stretched from the chin of the one on his left toward her perfectly formed softball–sized tits. Otherwise, both were completely naked.

“Surprise,” Zooey laughed before crawling next to him and ramming her tongue into his mouth.

As she did so, Abby undid the buckles and let the strap–on fall to the floor. Then she climbed up on Ben's other side and added her tongue to their ardent kiss.

“Do one of you care to explain?” he finally asked even as Abby began kneading his balls and Zooey stroked his stiffening dick. “I'm not complaining, mind you, but would like to know what's going on. Let me guess...Abby was the one with the strap–on, so I can at least tell you apart that way.”

“This time and just for now,” Zooey grinned wickedly, offering the pulsing head of his cock to her sister and smiling cheerfully when Abby licked off the drop of precum that bubbled to the tip. “Now that I see you like getting your ass fucked as much as me, you might not be so positive about which one of us is pounding you in the future.”

With that, she pushed him down on the bed to join her twin sister licking and sucking his cock and balls. When he was hard again, Zooey held his dick upright, inviting Abby to lower herself down and take every bit of his six–and–a–half–inch–long dick deep into her cunt. Zooey fingered Abby's clit until her sister's juices flooded her husband's cock and balls and his cum filled her twin's identical cunt.

A little while later, Abby called her husband and told him she was staying with her sister for the night to be safe since they had been drinking. She didn't mention it was mostly Ben's thick creamy cum, both directly from his throbbing cock and mixed with her sister's pussy juices as it oozed out of Zooey's cunt and asshole.

•••••

“Walt's turn next,” Zooey announced as the twins lay on either side of Ben idly fondling his deflated cock coated with both of their pussy juices and spittle the next morning.

“I probably shouldn't ask,” Ben said while lightly pinching a stiff nipple on each of them and not at all sure if it was his wife or her sister talking, “but what the fuck are you two scheming now?”

“Walt's always begging to ass fuck me,” Abby started to explain on his left, thereby momentarily identifying herself, “but I really don't like anyone touching my asshole in any way. Since my sister likes it so much, we figured we can switch to let him fuck her ass thinking it is me while I watch just like we did with you.”

“Fair is fair, honey,” Zooey added, leaning over to circle his right ear lobe with the tip of her tongue, “and if we really get lucky, he might be willing to give your ass a taste of his cock and cum too.”

“Oh, now that's something I would really like to see,” Abby chimed in, realizing her sister hit an agreeable chord with Ben by the way his cock twitched in her hand.

Zooey leaned across her husband's body to ram her tongue into her sister's mouth. As the kiss went on, Ben reached between their legs to drag a fingertip through both of their warm wet pussy slits. Zooey turned her head and thrust her tongue between his lips to swirl around his as Abby licked down his body until she could take his rigid cock into her mouth.

As his cock began to throb, Zooey flipped around, planting her dripping pussy on his face then added her tongue to her sister's on his dick. He started gagging on her pussy juices flooding into his mouth and down his throat just before his cock erupted, spraying both of their faces and coating their tongues.

•••••

“So how do we go about arranging this?” Abby asked as the three of them sipped coffee on the patio a half–hour later without bothering to get dressed after showering together.

“I suppose we try the same switch we did with Ben last night,” Zooey suggested. “Walt can't tell us apart any better than anyone else except Daddy.”

“He'll probably get suspicious if I have a sudden change of heart about letting him ass fuck me,” Abby continued while absentmindedly fondling her right nipple. “I've always been pretty insistent about not doing it since some guy thought I was you in college and really hurt me. Besides, we won't have the excuse of a strap–on present to set the tone.”

“Maybe we can get him high and horny at the same time and break down his inhibitions,” Ben piped in, causing the twins to turn their full attention to him, “and yours as well.”

“Does that mean you want to be a part of this scheme, as you call it, after all?” Abby giggled, leaning over to twirl the tip of his cock in two fingers. “I'm not objecting, just surprised.”

“It's been a long time since a guy I knew and liked fucked me, really fucked me hard and filled my bowels with warm sticky sperm,” he murmured softly as his dick stiffened in his sister–in–law's hand, “but last night and this morning has gotten me thinking about playing with men more openly since you both seem to enjoy the idea so much.”

“Well, I for one am loving the way your thinking is going,” Zooey grinned, adding her hand to her twin's on her husband's cock. “So what do you have in mind?”

“I have an appointment for my annual physical on Tuesday,” he started to explain while sitting back to give both of them easier access to his rapidly stiffening dick. “I'll just ask the doctor to prescribe some of those little blue pills guys use to get and stay hard. Meanwhile, one of you gets some edibles or, even better, high–octane cannabis oil from the dispensary in the strip mall. When we come over for dinner next Friday, you mix the oil and crushed–up pills with the food, a creamy dessert might be best. It won't take long for me and Walt to get raging hard–ons from the pills and we'll all be horny as hell from the pot, especially if we're chatting or even acting suggestively. Somehow the subject of ass–fucking comes up and Zooey offers to let Walt do her when Abby says she doesn't mind since she won't do it.”

“Damn, you came up with all that really fast just based on our simple question?” Abby said with admiration as she stroked him a little faster.

“I've had some pretty decent, or indecent actually, inspiration lately,” Ben laughed, getting to his feet and taking both of their hands to lead them back to the bedroom. “Besides, I can't get the picture out of my head of laying on my back with my legs draped over your husband's shoulders as Walt ravishes my asshole and fills me with his cum while the two of you lick and suck my cock dry and squirt on my hands and face and in my mouth.”

“We'll have to work out some practical details,” Zooey laughed as she pushed him on to his back on their bed, “but I'm sure my sister is more than willing to practice that last part with us right now.”

He fingered them both to explosive squirting orgasms as their tongues battled to lick up every drop of cum that erupted from his throbbing shaft.

••••••••••

(I do welcome any comments and will respond to all at aadirtyoldmaninphx1@proton.me. Please remember that NIFTY needs your support. If you want the stories to continue, it's up to you to donate.)