Date: Mon, 1 Feb 2021 15:01:26 -0600 From: John White Subject: Falling for Colton 5 Hey guys! Sorry for the delay, I am having a little bit of writers block over this. I have all these ideas but it just takes some time to get to them! As always, please consider donating to Nifty, they are amazing at letting us authors publish our works for you guys. The following story is a work of fiction. Any similarities to real humans is purely coincidental!! Please enjoy and please reach out to me with ideas for the story and what you like and don't like! I hope to have the next part out by the end of next week!! Part 5: The next few days passed by without much to say. Colton picked me up for school and we spent every available moment together. Finally, it was the last day of school, as tradition my friends and I always went to lunch since it was a half day. My best friends go to the school that's a town over. We've been close since pre-school and I know that they always have my back. Once we got to lunch Kason, Colton, Nicole, Layne, Beth and I all sat down at our favorite little Mexican restaurant in town to have a late lunch. Beth was my other half, I told her everything. It has been hard to keep a secret like this from her, I mean I told this girl everything, how could I keep something like this from her? As we sat down, Colton to my left and Beth to my right. I hadn't so much as picked up the menu when Beth grabbed me by the ear and whispered, "Spill. It." I looked over and said, "for one, ouch. And two I have no idea what you're talking about." "Nate and I are going to the bathroom." Beth announced as she stood up from the table. With that she basically pulled me to the back of the restaurant. Once in a corner she pushed me into the wall and said, "I know something is going on. Why the fuck would Colton, the most popular guy in school all of a sudden want to hang out with us." "Says you miss good at everything." It was true. Beth was almost annoyingly good at anything she tried. Started every year of high school in Softball and Volleyball. She ran track one time just because she was bored. "I still don't know what you're talking about." I say, trying to gain us some time, especially since I didn't know how Colton would feel about telling people about us, even if she was my best friend. "Oh my god, you're totally doing the jock." She exclaimed. I had to of turned three shades of red. "Beth you can't say anything. Especially not to Kason. He for sure doesn't know and I don't want him to find out yet. They're both on the football team and I know that would ruin Colton's rep with the team." "WHEN? HOW? WHY? I thought he was dating that crazy bitch???" she says. So I tell her the whole story about what went down at six flags and about our date and him asking me out. "But you can't tell anyone. No one knows outside of my family. You're the first person that I told." I finally finish, nervous about how she was going to react. "Well, I'm happy for you. And just know that no guy will ever be good enough for you but, he seems like he's a good one." With that we made our way back to the table and it seemed like everyone had already ordered. As I sat down Colton leaned over and whispered into my ear, "what was that all about?" "Just best friend talk. No need to worry." I whisper back. Colton placed his hand on my leg under the table and gave me a loving squeeze. "Whatever you say babe." As Beth made her way back to her seat she leaned over Colton and said under her breath, "You ever hurt him, and I kill you." And patted his head before she sat down. I looked at Colton and saw a glimpse of fear and maybe anger in his eyes before he smiled and said, "oh I don't plan on it." We sat around and chatted about the school year and our plans for the summer. Our group was inseparable in the summers. We spent every waking moment together and often had sleepovers at each other's houses. I was the only boy who was allowed to stay at the girls houses since well ya know. Colton and Kason talked about the upcoming season, our football team was historically really good, and they had a good chance at making yet another run to the state championship game. After lunch we all agreed to meet back up at Beth's house to swim. As Colton and I got into his truck his lips we're quickly on mine. After a passionate kiss he sat back in his seat. "What was that for?" I say as I let out a giggle. "Oh just because I can. And I've been waiting to do that the whole entire lunch." He says. "Listen Colton about telling Beth, she cornered me, and she figured it out without me saying anything." I blurt out trying to get it out of the way. Colton took a moment before answering, "I'm not mad. I can tell she's your best friend. If you trust her then I trust her too. But from now on, let's make the decision on who we tell together. I'm happy in our little bubble for now, I don't want to burst it just yet." This boy never ceases to amaze me with how thoughtful he is. I know how scary it can be to come out, especially in his situation. I know that it can't be easy. "Hey, we have a little bit of time to burn before we have to be over there. I need to grab my swim trunks anyways." Colton says with a shit eating grin on his face. I knew that this was heading in only one direction and I was not upset about it. We made our way to Colton's house which was empty with his parents both being at work. It was the first time I had ever been to his house. I big two-story house which was fitting for him to live in. Colton had the whole second floor to himself since both his older sisters had already moved out and started families. Colton's room looked exactly as I expected it too. Posters of football teams were hung on one wall and a wall of trophies from playing various sports were on the other. In the middle of the room was a big king size bed which was of course unmade. We would have to fix that. I plopped down on his bed and breathed in his scent. There was something about the cologne that he wore that was infectious to me. He always smelt so freaking good it drove me crazy. I was instantly hard as I took a deep breath of his scent. Colton took notice and crawled on the bed on top of me. "Oh, just being in my room does this to you huh?" Colton says giving me a kiss on the forehead. "I can't help it okay? Your smell is enough to get me hot for you babe." I answer kind of embarrassed that that was all it took to get me horny. "Well why don't we take care of that then." Colton says as he kissed his way down my body. He pulled up my shirt and started to slowly suck on my right nipple, after a few slow nibbles he kissed his way to my left. I let out a soft moan before grabbing Colton's head and pushing him into my chest. I was overcome with teenage hormones and needed more. I took control and flipped Colton on his back. I snaked my way down his body until I got to his belt. In one move I had it off. "Whoa there big boy, someone's excited aren't ya?" Colton says as I pull on his hard dick through the denim in his jeans. I pull out his gorgeous cock and just stare in awe of it. How did I get so lucky I ask myself again? I licked my way from the base of his dick to the head and swirl my tongue around it before taking a few teasing bobs down, never breaking eye contact with my stud as he looked down at me in pleasure. With one hand tugging at his big beautiful balls I slowly start to stroke the shaft of his member while sucking on the head. I tease the underside of his head while I work on the shaft. "Fuck baby, that feels so good. Ughhhh. Fuck! That feels amazing baby." Colton moans over and over again. I slowly start to work his big cock with my mouth flexing my throat as I went down taking more of his dick each time. Once I bottomed out on the base of his cock, I used my tongue to lap at his balls. Which got a scream of pleasure from Colton. "Fuck babe, if you keep that up, I'm gonna bust!" Colton basically screamed down at me. I put my work into overdrive, never one to back down from a challenge I started to quickly go up and down on his cock using my hand to jack him off as I did so. After a minute or so of this Colton's hand latched onto the back of my neck. He started to fuck my face with a vengeance, my eyes started to water from the attack. I tried my best not to gag but I could feel the feeling start to happen. Just when I was sure I was about to puke everywhere Colton's orgasm started. He released shot after shot of warm cum into my mouth, I quickly swallowed sure not to let any get away. After his intense orgasm Colton laid back in ecstasy. "Wow." Was all he could manage to get out. "I don't even want to go swimming anymore after that." Colton said with a chuckle. I climbed up his body and spooned into his warm body still sweaty from his intense orgasm. "Well, we have too. Plus your buddy Kason will surely miss you if you're not there." I shoot back at him playfully poking his sides. "Buuttttt, we could always stay here and just cuddle and watch a movie." He shoots back. "As much as I would love that, I need to get some sun on these white bones. I'm as pale as Edward Cullen right now." I say laughing. Swimming at Beth's was just what I needed after a long and somewhat weird school year. It felt so nice to swim with all my besties and of course Colton. It did cause a challenge not to grope each other while we were splashing around. Kason was none the wiser that there was anything going on between us two. It sucked that I had to keep this big of a secret from him, but after the restaurant fiasco with Macy, I couldn't risk anything getting back to her. The next few weeks went on without much to say. We spent every single day together and Colton stayed at my house several nights. My parents weren't too excited about it, but we usually made up a lie about his parents not wanting him to stay at his house alone when they weren't there, or we fell asleep watching a movie. The summer was shaping up to be the best one of our lives, until one day in the middle of June. Colton and I were in my yard doing some gardening for my Mom. Part of my summer chores were to do some odd things around the house before I could go hangout with my friends. Seeing as Colton was now my boyfriend, he got to do them with me so I could get done quicker. We were just about to wrap up when I familiar car pulled into my driveway. I knew immediately who it was and dreaded what was coming. Colton suddenly stiffened up beside me and I knew he was not ready for it either. Macy got out of her car and started walking towards us. Colton left my side saying, "macy, what the fuck are you doing here?" "Well it's good to see you too. Listen I need to talk to you. Right now." She says. "I have nothing to say to you. And I don't want to entertain whatever it is that you want." Colton spits back. Knowing that I had nothing to do with this conversation I wanted to walk away. But something was telling me that she had something serious to say to him. I decided against my better judgement and walked closer to them. "This doesn't pertain to you Nate. It's best if you butt out of it." Macy says to me. That seemed to anger Colton as he looks at her with as much hatred as someone can muster and says, "Leave him out of this. This is his house and if he wants to be here, he can." "Okay fine, I wanted to tell you alone but seeing as you can't spend five minutes away from butt pirate over here, I guess this will have to do." Macy says to which I scoff. It would take more than a few playground insults to offend me. "Colton.....I'm pregnant. And it's yours." She says. HOLY SHIT. It was like all the air around us went cold. Like the last molecule of oxygen in a chamber had suddenly been snatched away from us. I was lightheaded. I could see the confusion in Colton's eyes as he started to speak. "Okay, well are you going to keep it?" he asks. KEEP IT???? What on earth is he even thinking???? He was about to be a senior in high school, how could he even entertain the idea of having a kid right now? And what about us? What would that even mean? If he wants to keep this baby, then obviously he would want to be involved. There goes any chance for us to be together. I was not going to play stepdaddy to my boyfriend's ex's child. "I am. And I want us to get back together. This child deserves parents who are together. And before you say anything, I have dirt on the two of you which I don't mind sharing with the entire town. " Now I was sick to my stomach. Sure Colton and I weren't super careful when we showed our affection but it was never in a place that someone who shouldn't see would. WE never did anything in public that someone could see. "Prove it. Show me what it is you have." I say, my voice not sounding confident at all. Colton was at a loss for words. He looked like he had seen a ghost. Macy pulled out her phone and there it was, a picture of Colton holding me and us kissing in his backyard. Clearly, she had climbed the fence and hid behind a tree. I was mortified. Here she was blackmailing us and there was nothing we could do about it. Colton quickly regained his composure and said, "Okay, fine. Let's go to your house and talk to your parents about this." What the fuck. So that was it. He was just leaving me here with my thoughts and me freaking out over all of this. How was this even possible??? "Colton..." I start but he cuts me off. "Nate, this has nothing to do with you. That one kiss didn't mean anything. You kissed me knowing that I was straight. I tried to move past it and us keep hanging out, but I can't hang with the gay kid anymore. I'm not going to be the guy who hangs out with the lonely fag." He shoots back at me. My world just collapsed in front of me. I knew everything was too good to be true. I knew that It all had to be a mistake him even considering dating me. But one thing I knew, and he did too was that this was more than what he was letting on. He knew everything we had done wasn't some kiss or a one-time fling. "Fine. Get the fuck off my property and never speak to me again. Oh, and I hope your baby is ugly." I spit back turning and running into my house the tears already starting. They left in Macy's car and that was it. My life was over. I know Colton and I had only been dating for 2 months but it felt like so much longer. We had grown so close, he knew things about me that no one else knew, not even Beth. I felt so empty without him here. I cried so hard that I fell asleep from exhaustion. I woke up hours later to a knock on my door. "Can I come in?" it was Beth. Thank God. She took my silence as an answer and came in anyways. "Listen, I know you don't want to talk but I think you need to hear this." She started. "Fuck him. Fuck him for all of this pain that he is causing you. You are so much better off without him it's not even funny. He doesn't deserve how good you were to him. And he for sure doesn't deserve to be with you when he can't accept who he is." "How did you know?" I say through more tears that just seem to keep coming. "Well, he called me." She says. "What? What exactly did he have to say?" I question. "He told me what went down. That he said somethings that he didn't mean because he was mad about the situation. That he would never be able to make it up to you for what he said but that he was scared. Also, there is no logical way that she could be pregnant, Colton claims that they haven't had sex in months so even if she is pregnant it couldn't possibly be his." "That doesn't matter. He made it very clear he wants nothing to do with me. Even if it is true and it's not his, he said the most disgusting things to me. I don't want to be with someone who is so ashamed that he would say things like that to me." "That's true. Hey, you need cheering up so were going to Mama Rita's for dinner. SO get your ass up and go wash off your face because you look terrible." "Thanks, I guess." I say halfheartedly. I knew I could not be a prize to be won right now. Looking in the mirror Beth was right I did look like a hot mess, the tear stains and runny nose really brought out the blotchy red complexion I was sporting right now. After washing my face I finally looked at my phone after hours of avoiding what could be waiting on me. Sure enough there was 10 missed calls and 15 messages from Colton. I wasn't surprised that he reached out, more so surprised that he had the audacity to say something to me after what he said to me earlier. All of this to keep his fragile ego held together. "Nate. I am so unbelievably sorry for what I said to you earlier. I was so far out of line to do this. There is no way this kid is mine if she even is pregnant. I'm making her take a pregnancy test right now and I'm going to watch her do it so I can know for sure." A few texts later I received: "By the way, I know that I pretty much fucked up any chance of us ever being together again and I'm heartbroken over that. I said some things that I know aren't true and that I would never imagine saying to you. Just please hear me out. Meet me at our spot at 7:15 and I can explain everything." He couldn't possibly think that I would even consider showing up to talk to him, right? What makes him think that I would even want to see him right now. But the sad thing was, I did. I wanted answers, and to know why. Even if what I feared was true, I couldn't bear to hear it from him. I mean logically should I even hear him out. Regardless of what was said he doesn't get to dismiss what we had between us. He was the one who decided to do this, I made it clear that I wouldn't be the one who caused his ego to get shattered.