Date: Sun, 2 Jan 2022 21:48:49 +0000 From: David Greg Denton Subject: Benny - Part 5 Benny – Part 5 Gay, Incest, Stepfather, Stepson If you enjoy reading stories on Nifty, then don't forget to donate! It's easy, just follow the link http://donate.nifty.org/donate.html * * * * Their very first Poker Night was set for Friday. Joe was the only one who needed to arrive so the guys set up the table with poker chips and snacks while they waited. There was a knock on the door just a few minutes before seven. "I'll get it," announced Benny as he practically ran to the door. He opened it and greeted his favorite step-grandfather. "Hey Grandpa! Come on in." Benny held the door while Joe stepped inside then they hugged. He was carrying a case of beer which he had not been asked to bring. Paul saw it and said, "You didn't have to bring anything but yourself, Dad." Joe handed the beer to his grandson saying, "I just wanted to contribute since I can't host this thing at my house." "Understood," Paul said as he hugged his dad and led him into the dining room. Tom finished placed the last of the chips at Joe's spot then hugged his stepdad. As soon as they were all seated, Paul made an announcement. "I have a proposed change to the rules of the game before we get started. As you all know, Benny initially proposed that this be a game of strip poker with the winner getting to fuck the biggest loser. I'm proposing that we change it to the winner fucks the guy who comes in second instead." "Why the change, son?" "Because this way, no one person will try to go out first." He didn't look directly at Benny but the other two did. "And what makes you think that would be me?" They all chuckled and even Benny had to agree that it might be something he would do. "But what happens to the strip part of poker night?" Benny asked looking quite sad. Tom offered a compromise, "What do you guys say we keep that part in, for Benny, and still go with Paul's proposal? The one with the most chips at the end of the night fucks the one with the second most chips, naked or not." They all nodded then Benny asked another question, "We never did talk about what the other two do while the first two are fucking." "Good point, Ben. Suggestions?" Joe offered a solution, "Maybe they could hurry and clean up then watch while the others fuck?" "Interesting," Tom admitted then asked, "Any objections?" The other three shook their heads and they began to play. Joe was the first dealer. About a half hour into the game, there was a knock at the front door. Paul had ordered pizza to be delivered. Benny headed for the door, but Tom called out to him, "Put some clothes on, son." Benny said over his shoulder, "I lost them all in a card game. No can do." Just as he was about to open the door, Paul insisted that he at least cover up with the lap blanket from the couch. Benny was bummed but did as instructed. He opened the door and saw a guy from his history class. "Hey, Ren! I didn't know you delivered pizzas for Giuseppe's?" "Yeah," Ren replied. "It's my dad and uncle's place." "So which one is Giuseppe?" Benny asked. Ren chuckled and replied, "Neither. That would be my grandpa." He handed Benny the pizzas and Benny handed him a tip because his uncle had already paid for it by credit card. "Interesting outfit, there Benny." It was Benny's turn to laugh. "Ah, we're playing strip poker and I was not allowed to answer the door in my birthday suit." "Lost your clothes already?" "Yup, the guys are pretty ruthless," he replied with a smile. "Got any hot girls in there too?" Ren asked. "No, Ren... sorry. I'm gay. We pretty much all are." Ren's face registered a look of genuine surprise. "Oh... I didn't know. You know a couple of members of my rugby team are gay too." "Cool." Joe yelled from the other room that they were hungry. "Sorry, I gotta go. See you in class?" "Yeah... oh that reminds me... you're probably a little behind because of... well you know. I'm sorry for your loss, by the way." Benny thanked him, then Ren continued, "Anyway, so I was thinking if you needed help catching up, I'd be happy to be of assistance in that area." Benny was caught off guard by the offer but thought it was a great idea. "Thanks, I will need some help. Give me your phone for a sec?" Benny asked. Ren took out his phone and handed it to Benny who typed his number into the contacts then handed it back. "Text me and I'll call you back... see if we can set something up, okay?" "Anytime. See ya Benny." "See ya, Ren." Then he closed the door. As he walked into the kitchen with the pizzas, he was immediately grilled by the other three. "So you know the delivery boy?" Paul asked as he opened the two boxes and put a slice of pepperoni on his plate. "Yeah, we have history class together. He's really knowledgeable and he's offered to help get me back up to speed." "That's great, son. Is he cute?" Tom asked as he helped himself to a slice of pepperoni too. "Yes, Dad, but in a jock sort of way." Benny replied helping himself to a piece of the cheese pizza. "Is that a bad thing?" Grandpa Joe asked as he too took a slice of the cheese to start. "No. Just not my usual type. That's all." It did get Benny thinking that while he loved his dad, uncle and grandpa, he needed to interact with more guys his own age. "Could he be?" joe asked. "Your type that is?" which brought Benny back, so he answered, "Yes. I think maybe he could." They finished eating then went back to the table where they played for another half an hour then counted up the chips. Paul and Benny had the least while Joe and Tom had the most. Tom ended up winning with Joe coming in a close second. Joe was secretly thrilled that he was going to get fucked by his stepson. And without letting on, Tom was equally excited by the prospect of fucking his stepdad. Paul and Benny cleaned up in record time and joined Tom and Joe in the bedroom. Tom told them they had to stand on either side of the bed and watch while Joe got plowed by his stepson. That way the big losers couldn't touch each other either. Benny was not happy with this new rule that his own father had come up with. While he wanted to be mad, he couldn't help but enjoy the show of his sweet grandpa getting fucked by Benny's dad while watching his Uncle Paul beat his meat. It was a win-win for everyone especially when Benny was the first to violate the new rule by reaching out to caress his uncle's butt. Paul did the same to his nephew's. They ended up diddling each other's holes while beating off. They all came within seconds of each other and agreed afterwards that they were looking forward to poker night the next Friday night. * Ren texted Benny the next day about meeting at his apartment on Sunday afternoon. Benny texted back that that would work. They arranged a time then Ren sent him the address. It turned out he lived above the pizzeria which Benny thought must be pretty convenient. He arrived on time and pushed the button. Ren buzzed him up then met him in the hall. "Hey, Ben! Good to see you again." Then Ren reached out to give him a bro hug. Benny reciprocated making sure not to get too close. He didn't want to freak the guy out. They got started right away and after a few hours Benny was all caught up. Ren called down and asked for a pizza. They talked while it was baking. "So you live with your dad?" "No, my dad and my uncle." "So your dad and your uncle..." He didn't know quite how to finish the thought. "This is gonna sound weird, but my dad and my uncle are actually stepbrothers. They dated long before my grandad met and married my grandma. They, my dad and my uncle, recently got back together after my dad left my mom." "Sounds complicated and weird." Benny laughed then Ren added, "I'm sorry, Benny, I didn't meant that the way it sounded." Benny and answered, "It's okay. To outsiders it probably does but not to us. We're just family." "So then I have to ask why you were playing strip poker with your family?" He genuinely looked confused so Benny helped him out. "As you know, Dad, my Uncle Paul, and I recently went through something pretty terrible. We were there for each other and it just so happened to bring us and my grandpa closer together." Benny hoped he hadn't scared Ren off by saying too much. Just then Ren got a text saying that his pizza was ready. "I have something to tell you but I have to go downstairs to get our pizza. I'll be back in a second." He took off before Benny could even say a word. When he got back a few minutes later, he took it straight to the kitchen. Benny had taken the liberty of getting plates and glasses out. Benny placed the pizza slices on the plates while Ren got them some beers from the fridge. "Have a seat, Ben." They both sat at the small table and began to eat while Ren summoned the courage to tell Benny what he shared with very few people. "Remember when I told you that a couple of guys on my rugby team are gay?' Benny nodded. Then Ren just blurted out, "I'm one of them. I'm gay too, Ben." That was a real surprise to Benny. He almost choked on his food. "Wow Ren! I did not see that one coming." "Yeah, I know. I'm a big, thick, rugby player history geek. I hardly believe it myself sometimes." Benny laughed and responded by saying, "We come in all shapes and sizes, Ren. I have a feeling you don't tell many people though." "No, I don't. I have to stay in the closet until I move out and get a real job. Until then, my super religious family can't know who I really am. It sucks." Benny placed his hand on top of Ren's and said, "I'm sorry you can't be out right now but just know that someday you will be." "Thanks, Benny. I do have one person in my family I can confide in. It's my Uncle Peter. He's gay too. In fact, he recently ran into an ex who he dated a long time ago and who's ex recently left his wife for him. It really messed him up that he missed out again. I ended up consoling him in probably the same way your family did each other. If you know what I mean." This was sounding a little too familiar to Benny so he had to ask, "Was his ex's name Paul by any chance?" "Yeah, why?" Then it dawned on him too. "You don't think your Uncle Paul is my Uncle Peter's ex, do you?" "I'm afraid I do. Small fucking world isn't it?" "Too fucking small." They both just shook their heads as they continued to eat. Then Benny thought of something he wanted to ask Ren, "When you said you comforted your uncle..." Ren nodded and said, "Yeah, we've been known to help each other out from time to time since we're both in the closet and can't openly date men." "Then you know how it is between family." "I do, Ben. I really do." After dinner, they said they'd see each other in class. Benny gave Ren a real hug before he opened the door and Ren gladly accepted, hugging back a little longer than he would normally. The two young men felt they might have found a kindred spirit in which they could confide and with whom they might possibly share more intimate experiences in the future. * Jim and Benny settled on Tuesday as their first workout day. They met at the gym, did their warmups on the treadmills, then headed to the weight room. Benny was spotting Jim while he was bench pressing a good amount for starters when he saw Ren walking toward them. Benny helped Jim put the bar back on the supports then said, "Hey, Ren! How ya doing?" "Good, Benny. You?" "Good. This is my friend Jim. Jim this is Ron from my history class." "Nice to meet you, Jim." "You too, Ren," Jim replied with a sour look on his face. "Well, I better leave you two to it. See ya later." Then he turned and went to the circuit training room. Benny and Jim continued to work out until Jim mentioned that he needed to get into the shower or he was going to be late for lab. Benny went with him and even considered taking a shower with Jim. but Ren came in and said, "Hey guys. I was just going to hit the sauna. Any takers?" Jim said he couldn't, but Benny was game. They all undressed then wrapped towels around themselves with Jim going in the direction of the showers and Benny and Ren going in the direction of the sauna. Benny thanked Jim for working out with him and said he'd see him in class. Ren tried to say once more that it was nice meeting Jim, but he just nodded and walked on by. Once Ren and Benny were seated on the top bench in the sauna, Ren started the conversation by asking Benny a question, "Have you slept with Jim yet?" "No," Benny answered a little defensively. He didn't think this was an appropriate question considering how short a time they'd known each other. "What made you ask that anyway?" "Because it's obvious he has feelings for you." "No he doesn't. We're just friends and workout buddies." "Well, he clearly wants to be more. You didn't see the way he looked at me. If he could, he'd bite my head off and shit down my neck." "First of all, eww!" That made Ren laugh. "And second, I'm going away for the summer. I can't get involved with anyone right now." Then he added, "Oh shit!" "What?" "I kissed him after the funeral... but it was really just to thank him for coming. That's all." "Well, it must have meant more to him than to you. If you're not ready to get serious with him, I'd let him know sooner rather than later," Ren offered. "You're right. I'll have to find a way to let him down easy. Thanks." "No problem. I'm not in a position to have a serious relationship with a guy right now either so I get it." Then he did something Benny hadn't counted on. He opened his towel showing Benny and half hard, uncut cock lying just below a well-trimmed bush. Benny liked what he saw, so he did the same showing Ron his half hard cut cock. "Nice," Ren said. "You too," Benny added. "Wanna have some fun?" Ren asked as he took his cock in his hand and started to stroke it. Benny took his own in his hand and started doin the same. "What if someone comes in?" "No one ever comes in at this time of day." Then Ren reached over and took over for Benny, stroking his long, pale cock. Benny did the same to Ren's thick, dark one. They started stroking each other while glancing occasionally at the door. They knew they didn't have much time because they might get caught at any minute. But that just made it all the more exciting. It was easy to reach quiet climaxes quickly and soon they were shooting their loads onto their partner's hands. "Wow, that was great, Benny." "Yeah, it was. Maybe we can do more next time? I mean if you want to... and definitely not here!" Ren laughed. "How about my place... next Sunday?" Then Ren added, "We could say we were studying." That made Benny laugh. "I'd be happy to study you more closely. I mean study with you more closely." They both laughed and agreed to meet at his apartment the following Sunday afternoon. They wiped their hands on their towels then left the sauna for nice, long, separate showers. (to be continued in Part 6)