Box Shaped Heart Ch. 20

By Laura S. Fox 

Copyright 2019 Laura S. Fox 

All Rights Reserved 

Gay Erotica 

Intended for Mature Audiences Only 

This story will contain graphic depictions of sexual intercourse, strong language and it is not meant for readers who are less than 18 years of age. 

Consider making a donation to Nifty by clicking the little blue button on the front page, as they help us all enjoy so many great stories, while aiding authors like me to display their work.


Chapter Twenty The Fixer-Upper

He almost felt tempted to walk through the door and yell `honey, I'm home', but somehow he wanted to take Aron by surprise. No such luck, though, as the guy was expecting him, his arms crossed over his chest and a stony look on his face.

"So, what do you want to tell me?" Aron spoke first.

"What? No smooches?" Carter opened his arms wide and walked towards Aron.

Apparently, the guy was not in the mood for his shenanigans.

"Where have you been and why did you turn off your phone?" Aron questioned him. "What if something happened to you? Do you have any idea how that would have made me feel?"

"I went to see David," Carter said bluntly.

Aron's face fell. It was like the guy was waiting for a verdict that he knew it wasn't going to be in his favor.

"Why didn't you tell me about him?" Carter questioned.

Great, now you really think you're the husband. Aren't you going too far with this charade?

I'm doing it for a good cause.

And the road to hell is paved with good intentions.


"Hey, I'm just asking," he spoke softly and touched Aron's arm.

The guy was looking at him, hesitating between panic and astonishment.

"Well, I talked to him, and just so you know, you don't have to go there, at least not for that, you know to watch some guys doing whatever they are doing there. I mean, well, if you really can't live without that," Carter began his argumentation, "I cannot really keep you, but, if there is something you want us to try, be it that you like to be tied up, or, I don't know, gagged, just tell me, and let's just do it at home."

Aron looked as if he needed to pick his jaw up from the floor.

"What? Do you think I cannot dominate you or something?" Carter frowned.

"I'm pretty certain you can do whatever you want with me because I thought you were going to say that you're going to file for divorce now that you know about my friendship with David. Wait, how did you learn ..."

"I figured it out," Carter said quickly. "And there was a card you dropped from your pockets. From David's club. So I went there, and talked to him."

"That seems like quite the intuition," Aron mumbled.

Aron was not going to buy that. He needed to act quickly.

"Hey, guess what I brought home from work," he said brightly.

"Wait, we need to talk about David," Aron stopped him.

Ah, damn, it wasn't going to be simple.

"The guy says you're just friends," he spoke.

"And do you believe him?" Aron asked, his voice a tad strained.

"Yeah. He seems like a cool dude."

Aron was blinking and looking at him like he could not believe he was hearing that.

"Why didn't you just ask me about him?" Aron questioned. "Or it is just me you don't believe?"

Fuck, fuck, the situation was getting out of hand. What would Alex do? Clearly, if he managed to stay married to Aron for two years, while cheating and breaking expensive vases and who knew what else, the guy had to have some tricks up his sleeve.

"I could always get bitchy and break something," he stared at Aron and made his best impersonation of an angry husband, crossing his arms over his chest and frowning. "Really, you left home without saying where you're going. Forgive me if I didn't think you would be willing to share this kind of information."

"I've been gone before, and you didn't really care to find out where I was," Aron said defensively. "You cared only about throwing tantrums and never letting me say a word. And forgive ME," Aron mimicked his words from earlier, "if I found that leaving for a few days to be away from you seemed the only way to save this train wreck of a marriage."

Carter stood there, stunned.

"Are we breaking up?" he murmured.

"No," Aron scowled. "I still love you. I'm not letting you go that easy. But some things are hard to swallow, okay?"

Carter could feel a joke coming right up, but even his troll brain had to agree now was not the time for that.

"Okay," he sighed.

Saving marriages was tiresome. He wasn't envying those marriage counselors at all.

"You always say you're sorry, but you still don't listen," Aron said bitterly.

"Well, I'm listening now. If you want to talk," he hurried to add.

Aron was staring at him, his eyes swimming in hurt.

"David is just a friend. Yes, I went to his club, and watched some guys performing on a stage, okay? I didn't fuck anyone," Aron shook his head. "Have I ever felt tempted? God knows I have. But I am a married man, and I'm not going to make a joke out of our marriage. You're faithful to me, I'm faithful to you. This is how it works."

Ouch. Big, big ouch.

"So what does David think?" Carter found himself talking.

"I thought you talked to him," Aron frowned again.

"Well, he seems like a busy man. I just wanted to know who he was. Now I know, and now I'm asking you about him. As I'm supposed to," he added quickly.

In retrospect, he could have just asked Aron directly, but no, he had been way too determined to find out who David was on his own. What did that make him? A jealous husband, like Alex was, of course. Completely in character.

Aron didn't look like he was buying that. But he continued to talk.

"David thinks I got the short end of the stick. He's frank like that. Are you sure you want to hear this?" he looked at Carter.

"Whatever he thinks, he doesn't think it anymore, I'm sure," Carter shrugged. "I told him how we fucked like rabbits."

Aron's eyes widened in surprise.

"You did? I mean, you're always so private about these things ..."

"Well, he was calling me a frigid housewife. I had to put him in his place," Carter explained.

"Wow," a ghost of a smile lit up Aron's face for a brief moment. "How did he react?"

"Surprised, and he also started talking about BDSM and stuff, like how I need to be trained or something. But forget about that," Carter waved. "I want to hear more from you."

"Okay," Aron breathed deeply. "He is a strong-willed man and he has his theories. I told him he's wrong and that he doesn't know you," he added in an apologetic tone.

"Stop mollycoddling me. Come on, shoot. What did he say about me?"

What did he say about us?

Shut up, brain, we're not asking that. This is about Aron's marriage.

Are we still lying to ourselves that we're some goody two shoes?

Shut up already.

"He thinks you don't love me," Aron spoke and stared at Carter, waiting for a reaction. "Well, not as much as I love you, at least. He says you're the kind of guy who only wants to be loved, without giving anything back. But I don't think that. I think you're insecure and that I should love you more until you don't feel like that at all. It's just that ... It gets hard sometimes. So I just go talk to David, and while he doesn't approve of my attitude towards the whole thing, he listens, and that's something I need. God knows why he's doing this for me, though. I guess it's not his idea of fun to hear me complaining about how I cannot manage to be a good enough husband for you."

"He's a good friend," Carter supplied right away. "How did you two meet, by the way?"

"It was through a mutual friend, 7-8 years ago. He wanted to get his club off the ground. I like the idea and told him so. There was some money he still needed to open, so I lent him the amount. He paid me back, don't worry," Aron hurried to say. "David really has a nose for business. Now he still jokes about how I should have just remained an investor and asked him for my share year after year. But this was not why I helped him with money that time."

"Then why?"

"I could tell he was passionate about it. Well, it may look foolish of me to take some of the money my father gave me and just place it in the hands of a stranger, but I have no regrets. David put the money to good use and even gave it back to me with interest."

"Sounds like a hell of a story," Carter murmured. "How come I've never heard of it?"

How come we've never heard of it?

"Sorry to break it to you, Alex, but you're not exactly the listening type. I learned not to bore you to death with my past, or stories about my friends."

"Like Carter?"

"Yes, like him, too," Aron sighed. "But you wanted to know, so ..."

The man fell silent and just stared at him. What was he supposed to say now?

"Well, I'm glad you told me about David. And about what he said about ... us. It's okay, I'm not upset, you can go see him or talk to him. As long as he doesn't convince you that you should divorce."

C'mon, if this David dude is right, Aron would be better off without Alex the douchebag.

Shut up, I'm not going to break up with Aron.

Again, you're nothing but a placeholder.

"He wouldn't do that. And I have no plans to divorce you, I told you. I married you and I didn't do it on a whim," Aron said with determination.

"How come you didn't complain to your parents about ... your marriage trouble?" Carter asked.

Aron looked away embarrassed.

"I didn't want to worry them," the guy replied, his words a tad clipped.

"Wait, what aren't you telling me?" Carter picked up the change in Aron's attitude right away.

"C'mon, it's not like my mom was subtle about it," Aron mumbled. "She's not your biggest fan, as you know. But that's how mothers are, I think," he added quickly.

"Really? Your mom doesn't like me?" Carter asked, in shock.

He knew Aron's parents well. Seeing how much time he had spent under their roof, they had often joked about him being their other son. It was hard to imagine Clementine Ruskin not liking anyone. Especially a pretty boy like Alex. That was a bit of a shock.

"Well, I guess so," Aron murmured.

Would his own mom think the same thing about the person he was going to marry, that if he ever got to that point? He couldn't tell. Clementine loved her son and she surely wanted to see him happy.

"Eh, she's still a bit upset I bought you the Spyder," Aron continued, shaking his head. "Dad didn't say anything, but he likes to keep things to himself. And it's not like I have regrets about doing that. I think you deserve nice things," he murmured and looked at Carter with honest, loving eyes.

"Are you happy, Aron?" Carter asked directly, and to stop the mothball growing in his throat from getting bigger. "Being married?"

What the fuck? That douche hadn't even bought the car with his own money? Damn. Now that was a piece of info that was hard to swallow. And what was Aron getting out of this marriage anyway?

Aron sighed.

"I am, of course I am. I married the guy I love. It's impossible not to be happy. What more can I ask for?"

"I don't know, more than just sex once a week," Carter mumbled.

"Please don't mock me," Aron frowned.

"I'm not. It's just that it really feels like you're really getting the short end of the stick in this," Carter remembered what Aron had said about David's opinion on things.

"Are you making a case against yourself now? Really, Alex, I have no idea what angle you're working now, but I feel like it won't end up well for me. As always," Aron said, running one hand through his short hair in exasperation, "I cannot tell where I stand with you. What do you want me to say? That I'm always happy? It would be a lie. Marriage is not just milk and honey."

"I don't remember seeing your folks fighting," Carter blurted out.

If there was someone to take after for a successful marriage, those were Aron's parents. Carter knew his childhood and teenage years had been so happy because he had practically lived under their roof.

"Well, you've seen them very little, but it's true that they get along fine," Aron admitted, unaware of his temporary's husband real knowledge of his parents' marriage. "But couples are different. What works for some, may not work for others. And as long as I stick with you, as long as you're my husband, we will pull it through. That's what marriage is about."

"Okay," Carter mumbled. "It's okay."

It's not okay. Alex is still a cheater.

Yeah, but I'm here. I can fix this.

In your dreams.

He chose to ignore that thought. Aron looked so dejected, standing there, his eyes cast down, his face all a frown, that he knew that he needed to do something. So he closed the space between them and took Aron into his arms.

"I trust you," he said, pulling Aron as close as he could.

The guy seemed hesitant at first, probably still wondering how come half the breakable valuables around weren't flying out the window right now but he hugged back.

"You really are changed," Aron murmured into his hair. "I hope you stay this way. You would make my job a little easier, you know?" he chuckled. "Regardless of everything I sometimes say when I'm pissed, I want you and no one else, and if I have to work hard to deserve you, then so be it."

"Okay," Carter said softly. "Okay."

"Now, what did you want to show me?" Aron nuzzled his ear slowly.

"Ah, something," Carter laughed and pushed Aron away so he could pick up the box he had left by the door.

To his ears, his laughter sounded hollow.

And what do you want?

Nothing, just Aron to be happy.

Then you know what you have to do.

"Just look at this crazy stuff," he turned away and presented Aron one piece of garment, pulling at the weird straps.

"Ah," Aron chuckled, "don't tell me you went out of your way to buy such a thing."

"Didn't have to. It's kind of a gift," he chirped away.

Was it really that easy to impersonate someone else? Maybe he could compete for an Oscar.

"The guys for whom I pose almost naked on Instagram thought about sending this naughty stuff. What do you think?" he asked.

"I think you should first have a shower while I put together dinner, and then you can put on a little fashion show just for me. What do you say?"

Carter grinned, feeling almost happy. Was this how delusional people came into being? He was pretty certain that the answer was `yes'. If after all this, he was going to become a bum on the street, singing serenades and dreaming about riding imaginary horses on the streets of the city, he was not going to be surprised. Not that he could be surprised in any way, seeing that he was just going to be insane and embrace his new reality.

"Baby?" Aron woke him up from his brooding. "Are you really okay?"

"Yes, sure thing," he shook his head and headed for the bathroom.

This tumbling down the rabbit hole? It was just getting weirder.


"Hmm," Aron murmured. "Now make a slow turn, bend, and ..."

"Hey, aren't you objectifying me a little here?" Carter protested.

He had been the one with the idea of showing Aron the naughty lingerie, but, for some reason, he didn't feel particularly at ease. Maybe he was letting other things get in the way.

Like your conscience.

Hey, I'm trying here.

It looks like something else from here.

Like what?

Like you don't want Alex to ever wake ...

Shut. The fuck. Up.

What was the solution for a dirty conscience? Forgetting, maybe. But there was no way for him to forget, as long as he practically wore Alex's body, and, at the same time, was falling ...


That was not a door to walk through. Not now. Not ever.

"Damn, you're so sexy. I must be the luckiest man alive," Aron spoke, drawling the words. "Come here."

He stopped by the edge of the bed, looking at Aron. Was this how being happy was like? Too bad he was just practically staring through a window, or over the fence at his neighbors. He had never pegged himself as a voyeur before. And this was the most intimate thing he can defile by being ... just who he was. It was not his place to have Aron look at him like that. And, being the imposter he was, he even dared to enjoy it.

Aron was oblivious to the storm of thoughts clouding his mind. Maybe he was getting better at hiding. The man on the bed moved and a strong hand reached for him, caressing the inside of his elbow, while Aron searched for his eyes with his.

"Can I make love to you?" Aron asked simply.

He nodded and climbed the bed, pushing Aron on his back and making their lips touch. But this time, it didn't look like Aron was in the mood to be dominated by his skinny husband. The tables soon turned and he was the one on his back, with the other hovering over him.

"You're amazing," Aron cooed. "I wish I could stare at you like this forever."

"Take a picture, it will last longer," he replied, smiling.

"Not a bad idea," Aron's face lit up and the guy reached for his phone.

"Hey, what are you doing?" he eyed the other cautiously.

"I'm taking a picture of you, like this," Aron replied.

He was trapped between the guy's strong thighs. Seeing how much he could pose almost naked in front of strangers, it was pretty damn weird he was feeling so embarrassed right now. Maybe it was because he was really naked. Not naked-naked, as at least, in front, the naughty undies still covered his manhood, even if barely. But he could feel his soul laid bare, and that was making him feel like he could barely take having Aron look at him with those deep, full of meaning eyes.

"Oh, damn, baby, do you have any idea how you look?" Aron breathed out. "It's like there's something in your eyes right now ..."

"Are we fucking or making conversation now?" he blurted out.

"Someone's a little impatient," Aron smiled and began rubbing Carter's cock through the flimsy pants. "Hmm, this material feels nice."

"What are you still doing with that phone?" Carter chided his husband of circumstances.

"Well, I think I want more than a picture. A video is worth a thousand pictures."

"Or it depends on how many frames per second you're shooting," Carter replied.

Aron looked at him over the phone now.

"Is this your idea of killing the mood? Cause it's not working," Aron joked. "Come on, feel this."

If Aron wanted to derail him from calculating how many frames were going to be in a full minute, to have then a basis for calculating how many there were going to be for the whole video Aron wanted to record, well, he was doing a pretty good job.

Aron wore nothing but some tight boxers, and the contour of his superb cock was showing through the fabric. It was really pleasant to feel it like this.

"Are you going to shoot how we fuck?" he mumbled, as his fingers were curling, as much as it was possible, over the lengthening cock in Aron's underwear.

Not that he disliked the idea. What he disliked was that it wasn't him here. Damn, he wasn't really here, was he? He raised his eyes to meet Aron's, and the man gave him a reassuring smile.

"I want this memory of us," Aron replied. "I'm just so happy now. Will you let me, baby?"

"Yeah, of course I let you," Carter said and grabbed the man's manhood tightly, making him hiss. "Now are you going to fuck with your underwear on?"

"No, how about you help me out of it?" Aron asked.

What did it feel so nice to undress Aron? For him, it seemed like he was unraveling a present on Christmas day. The guy's cock bounced the moment it was freed. Struggling to get Aron completely out of his undies proved to be a much more complicated business, seeing that the guy preferred to laugh and try to get everything on his phone. Carter growled and pushed the guy on his back, to get rid of the underwear for good.

As he reached for his own, Aron stopped him.

"I want to fuck you in it," the man explained.

"Well, what do you know?" Carter joked. "At least, these serve a purpose, after all."

"What purpose?" Aron managed to get on top again.

"To make you hard," Carter bit his lips and grabbed Aron's erect cock with both hands.

"My husband is in my bed, with a naked ass, while some sexy underwear barely covers his cock. How do you expect me to be?"

"Hmm, maybe an outstanding member of the community, restrained and civilized," Carter joked.

"I definitely have a member here," Aron caught his cock by its base, almost making it slip from Carter's fingers. "And I think it's pretty outstanding, don't you think?"

"Definitely," Carter laughed.

Well, he wasn't going to laugh for long. Aron began to maneuver him gently, but firmly, making him lay on his fours, preoccupied with taking a good look at his ass.

"Baby, do you have any idea how nice you look like this," Aron said breathily. "It's like you're even more than naked."

"Well, apparently, these are from some Blue Desire collection or something," Carter laughed.

Not for long, as Aron was slapping his naked butt with a hard cock, showing his impatience.

"Come, turn, I want you from the front," Aron turned.

It was easy to be Alex and have such a supple, easy to manipulate body. Soon he was on his back, with his legs parted and pushed up. Several seconds later, he shuddered as Aron's fingers pressed slowly against his entrance, slick with lubricant, making sure to massage the area right above, making him feel his cock hardening without even being touched directly.

Aron soon replaced his fingers with the blunt head of his cock but continued to rub against the skin.

Fuck, this felt pleasant. Like really pleasant. He hummed to express his satisfaction. Normally, he wouldn't have been against being taken fast, especially since he could feel how hard Aron was, but he was appreciating this kind of teasing. Aron started to sink inside his body, but only little by little, controlling his descent with his hand.

"Oh, fuck," Carter moaned, as he began to feel the stretch.

"So nice of the guys to give you this sexy underwear. I hope they realize that whoever wears such a thing is sure to get fucked really good," Aron joked, but his voice was strained.

"Shut up already, and get to work," he mumbled.

Aron was moving slowly, despite his encouragements. And he had some other needs to tend to. Aron's hand was quick to move his away and strong fingers pressed against Carter's manhood, without releasing it from the sexy underwear.

"Your cock's peeking out, how cute," Aron teased, using his fingers to brush over the head of Carter's cock that, indeed, had managed to break itself free over the waistband of the undies.

"Uh, that's a bit too much," he complained. "Or too little, I don't know. At least fuck me good, would you?"

"Most obliged," Aron joked. "Fuck, baby," he moaned, as he pushed inside deeper.

Okay, so Aron was a bit of a sadist because he was only using the tip of his fingers to tease Carter's cock, over the mushroom head, again and again. At least, the pressure in his ass was bearing fruit. He felt so damn fool, and it was damn pleasant.

"Hmm, love your big cock," he murmured, biting his bottom lip and turning his head to hide it into the pillow.

"You should see yourself," Aron spoke breathily. "You will, later," he added with a smirk, as he continued to hold his phone.

"I have no idea how you can concentrate while using your phone," he wondered out loud.

"Your ass is gripping my cock so tightly, it practically does all the work," Aron smiled.

Wow, Aron was going in and out with increased speed now. Carter chose to rest his feet on the guy's strong thighs for leverage. At the same time, his hands were searching wildly for the crumpled sheets, for something to hold on to.

"Fuck, I love your face when you show how much you like it," Aron praised him. "Sorry if I'm going to pound your ass right now. Here, take this and continue. Now I really have to concentrate."

He took the phone from Aron's hand. Oh, this is not a bad idea at all, not at all, not at all ...

Stop looping.


Aron looked amazing, the sweat making his skin glisten, his hooded eyes sexy, the way he licked his lips sending jolt after jolt of pleasure right into Carter's cortex. He lowered the phone, straightening up on one elbow, just so he could catch the act of fucking on digital memory.

He could not believe his pleasure could shoot much higher. Yet, it did, as he looked at how Aron's cock was sliding in and out of his ass like a well-lubed piston. They were like a marvelous machine right now, working together. He could no longer repress his moans.

"Fuck, baby, I want to see you come," Aron whispered.

This time, Aron gave up on teasing and pulled Carter's cock out to give it a good rub. It was fascinating to catch all this on camera, Carter thought, as he looked how Aron was pumping his cock good.

"Fuck," he threw his head back and dropped the phone, as he started coming.

"Yes, baby, yes, like this. I'm coming, too," Aron shouted back.

That moment, that perfect moment, when they stood still, like that, Aron wrenched deep inside him, his own body affected only by the shudders of the aftermath, that was simply everything.

Aron dropped on top of him with a small growl of satisfaction, locking lips with him. And they continued to kiss, pressed together, unaware of all the sweat and the cum between them, for minutes.

"So, you didn't catch the grand finale, did you?" Aron laughed when they finally found breathing was still necessary to live and broke their kiss.

"Sorry about that," Carter mumbled, smiling sheepishly.

"No sweat," Aron waved. "You just need more practice."

"Really?" Carter glared.

"Really," Aron confirmed. "I plan an entire collection."

"What for? It's not like a family album, you can't really show it to anyone," Carter snickered.

"Yeah, but we can look at it," Aron replied. "I think it would be hot."

"Yeah, I guess."

Yeah, it would be hot. But it would still not be him there, in those videos. How was he going to let go of this? When Alex was going to return as the rightful owner of this body, and this hunk of a husband? Because that was bound to happen. Because he could not be happy. Because he was a fraud, and he was not going to escape unpunished.


Author's note:

If you like this story and you want to support me while writing it, here is my Patreon account:

My patrons receive early access to chapters, complete books, and other nice extras.

The latest book I'm offering all my patrons is this:

The Worst Kind Of Hero


Ramon knows what he wants, and that is to have one heated encounter with a certain beautiful male celebrity who wouldn't give two cents on someone like him. The good news is that sometimes, dreams do come true, even when you're just a piece of street trash.

Lennart has no idea why he lets someone like Ramon get into his car and have wild sex with him. It may be just boredom, or the guy's brazen attitude just gets to him somehow.

It all looks like nothing but a quick hook-up with no follow-up. That until they meet again. And then?

Then they hit the ground running, with paid assassins on their tails.